Katie Holmes has been popping up on the Grazia best dressed list for a while now - in fact ever since she started rehearsing for her current Broadway show- All My Sons. First she was rocking boyfriend jeans like no other, then a master class in dressed down chic- which has become her signature look (jeans or leggings paired with pretty dresses and long belted cardies) so we were as bemused as the next by Katie's latest look which was papped on a shopping trip (with cute as a button daughter Suri in tow this week)...naturally we're loving her tartan D&G maxi which ruled the A/W runway shows in Milan but why she's chosen to swamp it in a sea of black knit is anyone's guess....leave the knitwear to your leggings combos and let your dress make the statement Mrs. Cruise. We must add a quick trip to the tailor wouldn't go a miss she's cleaning the streets of New York as she walks! But what do you think? Are you loving Kate's look or is this definitely an off day? Vote above.